Bureau of Justice Assistance
Bureau of Justice Assistance Bulletin sidebar graphic
 
Contents
sidebar bottom graphic

Pros and Cons

The main benefit of a cold case squad is that it reduces the backlog of unsolved homicide cases. The arrest of suspects in one cold case may either solve other cases (through new leads and information from those suspects) or prevent new ones (by keeping killers from committing other crimes). A cold case squad’s success in even one case can lead to positive feedback from a family that had been frustrated by law enforcement’s previous inability to solve the death of a loved one. The sense of justice and closure gained by the victim’s family when a case is closed cannot be overestimated. Even clearing previous suspects from suspicion can be helpful both to the families and the investigators. Arrests made in old cases also provide a good opportunity to present the community with a positive image of police who never stop caring about unsolved cases.

A cold case squad, however, also requires significant staffing and financial resources to pursue leads and track suspects. In addition, it requires input from potentially uncooperative or reluctant parties, especially the community, the victim’s family, and witnesses. A cold case squad’s success in closing cases and encouraging other investigations may actually hamper its effectiveness if resources for pursuing a flood of additional leads are not available.

Previous Next Back to Top