U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Police Use of Discretion: A Comparison of Community, System, and Officer Expectations

NCJ Number
107935
Author(s)
H H Nees
Date Published
1986
Length
206 pages
Annotation
This descriptive, exploratory study of police discretion examined the perceived appropriate response to a variety of petty offenses depicted in vignettes among police officers of varying ranks in 8 Boulder County, Colo., police agencies; 11 probation officers; 21 prosecuting and 52 defense attorneys; 16 judges; and 1,183 citizens.
Abstract
Respondents were asked to specify the appropriate reaction for each offense from among options ranging from take no action to arrest (jail). In most cases, differences among groups and within groups were minor; the differences were largely among the options of (1) take no action, warn, or refer to social services or (2) between issue a summons and arrest. In no case did one significant portion of any group surveyed choose the option of take no action while another chose the option of summons or jail. In general, police responses reflected the desires of citizens in their communities. Court personnel were more likely to differ from police, being more lenient in some cases and more punitive in others. Survey instruments and additional data are appended. Tables, chapter notes, approximately 150 references.