U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Theory, Pseudotheory, and Metatheory (From Advances in Criminological Theory, V 1, P 127-145, 1989, William S Laufer and Freda Adler, eds. -- See NCJ-115630)

NCJ Number
115638
Author(s)
J McCord
Date Published
1989
Length
19 pages
Annotation
Using a cheese metaphor, this paper discusses and distinguishes crime-cause theories and then addresses metatheoretical issues, suggesting that adequate theories should meet criteria that include giving an account of 'pretested facts.'
Abstract
'Hard' theories successfully describe the particular sets of events for which they have been designed. Their weaknesses are that theories appear to be confirmed by instances for which the theory has no obvious application, beliefs can be adjusted to allow for any evidence, and the way in which events are described determine which theories will be supported by the evidence. One of the more enduring 'fresh' theories about crime causes implicates broken homes. Too little attention, however, has been given alternative explanations to warrant concluding that broken homes cause crimes. 'Soft' theories spread into criminology after attaining a degree of acceptance as explanations for noncriminal behavior. These theories are so nebulous they continue to influence criminologists despite evidence that developments from their premises have failed to produce predicted results. 'Semihard' theories account for criminality in terms of rewards, punishments, and behavioral models. These theories assume universal psychological hedonism, although psychological hedonism has not received the critical examination that its role in these theories requires. New metatheories, which integrate 'simple' theories, are likely to improve criminality predictions, if for no other reason than they involve more variables than simple theories. As a trade-off, however, underlying conceptual confusions and false assumptions are likely to be more difficult to detect. Having a reasonable theory should require establishing that events occur in the sequences implied by the theory. 115 references.

Downloads

No download available

Availability