U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Dividing Line Between Punishment and Help: New Questions, Old Answers; Observations on the Juvenile Procedural Penal Code in Italy (From The Future of the Juvenile Justice System, P 251-259, 1991, Josine Junger-Tas and Leonieke Boendermaker, et al., eds. -- See NCJ-133019)

NCJ Number
133037
Author(s)
U Gatti; A Verde
Date Published
1991
Length
9 pages
Annotation
Italy's juvenile procedural penal code, which became effective in October 1989, mandates a few praiseworthy innovations, but also authorizes a dangerous expansion of the tools and structures that may be used in the course of penal proceedings.
Abstract
The laudable innovations pertain to the accusatory process and the limitation placed on the use of preventive measures. Overall, however, the reform is a reversal of the trend that has developed in Italy over the past 10 years, which has seen a gradual contraction of penal intervention paralleled by growth in local social services which separate the penal and welfare mechanisms. The reform under the law favors the rehabilitative model, characterized by a wide range of interventions and structures that aim at rehabilitation in the context of punishment. Its application methods risk opening the door to a dangerous dominance of penal requirements over welfare needs. Under the act, there is the potential for the transfer of welfare institutions to the penal sector. Group homes are likely to become jail-like. Preventive measures have a restrictive treatment quality and may be applied prior to determination of guilt for an offense. Rather than focusing on alternatives to a juvenile penal system, the new law returns to the past in an attempt to enforce rehabilitation in a restrictive penal context. 5 references