U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Moving and Touching Stowed or Checked Luggage

NCJ Number
175869
Journal
FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin Volume: 67 Issue: 12 Dated: December 1998 Pages: 18-24
Author(s)
J S Walker
Date Published
1998
Length
7 pages
Annotation
Officers must consider a number of Fourth Amendment issues when moving and touching luggage stowed or checked with a common carrier.
Abstract
This article examines whether a law enforcement officer's movement of passenger bags in the overhead bin of a bus constitutes a Fourth Amendment seizure. It also considers whether an officer's feeling of the exterior of the bags in such a scenario constitutes a Fourth Amendment search. A review of relevant court cases concludes that the movement of a bag in the overhead bin is not a meaningful interference with a person's possessory interest in the bag and therefore does not constitute a seizure. Further, the lifting of a bag will not be considered a search by the courts. Also, lightly compressing or "poofing" the sides of a bag for either the officer or a drug dog to smell the bag most likely will not be considered a search. Actively manipulating the outside of a bag with the entire hand to feel what is in the bag may or may not be considered a search. Of the three courts that have addressed the issue to date, one Federal court of appeals has found such action to be a search (United States v. Nicholson; 10th Cir. 1998), and another Federal court of appeals and a State court have reached the opposite conclusion (United States v. McDonald, 7th Cir; State v. Peters, Ariz., 1997). Finally, touching a bag in a violent, extreme, and unreasonable manner, such as throwing and breaking or crushing a bag, is a violation of the Fourth Amendment. Because courts are divided over the degree of manipulation of a stowed or checked bag that is permitted, officers should consult with their department's legal advisors before engaging in a warrantless manipulation of such luggage. 38 footnotes