U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Problem-Oriented Evaluation? Evaluating Problem-Oriented Policing Initiatives (From Crime Reduction and Problem-Oriented Policing, P 183-216, 2003, Karen Bullock and Nick Tilley, eds. -- See NCJ-204054)

NCJ Number
204060
Author(s)
Mario Matassa; Tim Newburn
Date Published
2003
Length
34 pages
Annotation
This examination of separate but related evaluations of three British problem-oriented policing initiatives designed to counter hate crime focuses on the role of the evaluator in relation to problem-oriented policing (POP) initiatives.
Abstract
The tactics and interventions used in the anti-hate crime initiatives varied significantly across and within programs and between the three sites. All the projects were delivered within a partnership framework. The emphases of the programs varied, but a number of common themes emerged. These included enforcement, education and awareness-raising, victim support, community development and (potential) offender identification, deterrence, and rehabilitation. The independent evaluations of these projects experienced the five major obstacles to the evaluation of multiagency crime partnerships identified by Rosenbaum (2002). These are the complexity of interventions; the complexity of contextual variables; the dynamic, changing nature of interventions; the diversity of intervention processes and outcomes; and the lack of optimal conditions for traditional experimental research. This chapter, however, focuses on a sixth obstacle, i.e., evaluation implementation failure and its variant implementation breakdown. In evaluating various Home Office-sponsored projects, priority has been given to an independent evaluation by researchers who have had no connection to the project. Although the aim of achieving an objective evaluation is laudable, it is impractical to exclude evaluators from project planning and design, particularly in the case of complex problem-oriented policing projects. For these projects, it is important that evaluators be involved in the development of the project itself, otherwise evaluation measures may be difficult if not impossible to identify and quantify. The professionalism of evaluators should make it possible for them to be involved in project planning and implementation and still be objective in assessing the project's implementation process and outcomes. 5 notes and 40 references

Downloads

No download available

Availability