U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

What Doctors and Policymakers Should Know: Battered Women's Views About Mandatory Medical Reporting Laws

NCJ Number
205828
Journal
Journal of Criminal Justice Volume: 32 Issue: 3 Dated: May/June 2004 Pages: 207-221
Author(s)
Alisa Smith; Kristin Parsons Winokur
Editor(s)
Kent B. Joscelyn
Date Published
May 2004
Length
15 pages
Annotation
This study explored battered women’s views regarding the effectiveness of mandatory medical reporting laws using four separate attitudinal measures of support for these laws.
Abstract
The criminal justice response to domestic violence has changed tremendously in recent decades with medical professionals in 45 States and the District of Columbia required by law to report cases of domestic violence to law enforcement (mandatory medical reporting). It is uncertain whether victims favor these laws or are negatively affected by unintended consequences arising from mandatory reporting. This study surveyed battered women residing in shelters across the United States and asked them about their views concerning laws that require doctors and nurses to report to police injuries that they believe resulted from domestic violence. Specifically, they were asked if they supported the law, if they thought the law would benefit them and others in their situation, and whether they would be more or less likely to seek medical attention for domestic violence injuries in a community with this law. Four attitudinal measures were used: ADOPT-adopt mandatory reporting laws; BENFSELF- mandatory reporting laws would benefit you; BENFOTHR- mandatory reporting laws would benefit others; and REPORT- where there are mandatory reporting laws, would there be more of or less of a likelihood that medical treatment would be sought for domestic violence injuries. Three factors were used that influence whether battered women contacted the police or sought other forms of help: demographic, situational, and legal. The findings indicate that three of the four measures, ADOPT, BENFSELF, and BENFOTHR, demonstrated little variation across all factors. The fourth measure, REPORT, produced a number of significant relationships among the demographic, situational, and legal factors. Implications of the research are presented. References