U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Understanding Women's Heightened Risk of Violence in Common-Law Unions: Revisiting the Selection and Relationship Hypotheses

NCJ Number
205984
Journal
Violence Against Women Volume: 10 Issue: 6 Dated: June 2004 Pages: 626-651
Author(s)
Douglas A. Brownridge
Editor(s)
Aysan Sev'er, Myrna Dawson, Holly Johnson
Date Published
June 2004
Length
26 pages
Annotation
This study examined the relationship between cohabitating women in Canada and their increased risk of violence.
Abstract
Past research has consistently linked cohabitation to a heightened risk of violence against women. However, recent evidence suggests that partner violence against women is decreasing in Canada. This raises the question of whether the decrease in prevalence of violence against women can, in part, be linked to a decrease in violence in common-law unions. To understand this trend, this study begins with a brief elaboration of the 2000 Brownridge and Halli theoretical framework and its application to current trends in cohabitation and violence in Canada. This framework analytically distinguishes risk markers of violence as either selection or relationship characteristics. An application of the theoretical framework suggests the possibility that as cohabitation becomes more common or normative in Canada, the selection bias of certain types of people predominantly entering into cohabitation may be reduced, lending them to become more like marital unions. The study then used a recently collected representative sample of Canadians to test the hypothesis that as cohabitation becomes more normative in Canada, the prevalence of violence in cohabiting unions would decrease relative to the prevalence of violence in marital unions. The study then tested the selection and relationship hypotheses derived from the framework to understand how selection and relationship factors operate in the relationship between cohabitation and violence at the turn of the millennium. Data for the study were from Statistics Canada’s cycle 13 of the General Social Survey (GSS). The results show that cohabiting women in Canada are more than twice as likely as married women to report experiencing violence over 1- and 5 year time frames. As hypothesized, cohabitating women in Canada remain at a heightened risk of partner violence relative to married women. Overall, several indications in this study suggest that if current trends continue, as cohabitation becomes normative, the selection bias will be reduced and it would be expected that the differential rates of violence in cohabiting and marital unions to converge. References

Downloads

No download available

Availability