U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Does the Form of Question Repetition Have an Effect on Children's Recall Accuracy and Consistency?

NCJ Number
229120
Journal
International Journal of Police Science & Management Volume: 11 Issue: 4 Dated: Winter 2009 Pages: 460-475
Author(s)
Sarah J. Krahenbuhl; Mark Blades
Date Published
2009
Length
16 pages
Annotation
This study examined the effect of various forms of question repetition on children's accuracy and consistency in interviews.
Abstract
The study found that a third of the children's responses to repeated questions changed. The largest number of response changes occurred the first time a question was repeated. Most often, children gave a different answer the first time a question was repeated, and then they maintained this answer when the question was repeated a second time. Generally, the accuracy of responses declined after the initial question, such that repeating a question resulted in less accurate responses. This decline in accuracy occurred whether or not a question was repeated once or twice. This confirmed previous findings from similar research. If insufficient detail has been provided in the initial free narrative given by the child, questions must be asked, so suggesting that repetition should not be used in interviews is impractical. Although an implicit assumption of repeating a question is that the repetition will elicit a more detailed or accurate answer, this is not usually the case. In accordance with previous findings, the current study found that accuracy of responses was greater in the older age group compared with the youngest age group; however, differences in age groups was less marked than expected in the accuracy of responses to repeated questions. Another finding was that questions repeated verbatim resulted in fewer changed responses to repeated questions, compared to repeating questions in another form but with the intent of eliciting the same type of information. Thus, when a question needs to be asked more than once, a verbatim repetition is the preferred form. The study involved 160 children from 3 age groups. 3 tables, 3 figures, and 30 references