U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

First-Line Supervision Under Compstat and Community Policing: Lessons From Six Agencies

NCJ Number
235952
Author(s)
James J. Willis
Date Published
July 2011
Length
36 pages
Annotation
This third of three reports on an examination of the potential linkages between Compstat and community policing explains what was learned from six on-site focus groups conducted with front-line supervisors, most of whom supervised patrol or community-policing officers.
Abstract
The six police agencies, although differing in size and organization, all reported fully implementing Compstat and community policing. The focus groups discussed how sergeants made decisions and offered guidance on crime and disorder problems. Overall, Compstat's contribution to a data-rich environment helped sergeants identify emerging crime problems and focus patrol resources, but Compstat data were rarely used to promote innovative responses to those problems. Regarding community policing, sergeants expressed strong support for addressing the needs of community residents and providing high-quality service, but they viewed their primary obligation as answering calls for service. The absence of specific reform structures designed to facilitate close working relationships between sergeants, their officers, and local residents and to buffer patrol from the 911 workload made it difficult for patrol sergeants to engage in the kind of in-depth problem solving activities supported by community policing advocates. This approach fell to a relatively small number of community policing specialists. Given these findings, which are consistent with the other reports on this issue, this report suggests envisioning alternative configurations for these reforms so as to improve their strategic focus. Although the experiences of these six police agencies do not necessarily represent those of all departments that have implemented both Compstat and community policing, they do suggest that the role of first-line supervision is underdeveloped. The challenge to policymakers and researchers is to consider how first-line supervision could be restructured to the mutual benefit of both the implementation of Compstat and community policing.