U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

OPTIMUM ENFORCEMENT OF LAWS (FROM ECONOMICS OF CRIME AND LAW ENFORCEMENT, 1976 BY LEE R MCPHETERS AND WILLIAM B STRONGE - SEE NCJ-37726)

NCJ Number
37729
Author(s)
G J STIGLER
Date Published
1976
Length
14 pages
Annotation
THE GOAL OF ENFORCEMENT IS TO ACHIEVE THAT DEGREE OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE RULE OF PRESCRIBED (OR PROSCRIBED) BEHAVIOR THAT THE SOCIETY BELIEVES IT CAN AFFORD.
Abstract
THE EXTENT OF ENFORCEMENT OF LAWS DEPENDS UPON THE AMOUNT OF RESOURCES DEVOTED TO THE TASK. ANOTHER SOURCE OF LIMITATION OF PUNISHMENT (OR ENFORCEMENT) ARISES OUT OF THE NATURE OF THE SUPPLY OF OFFENSES. THE DETERMINANTS OF SUPPLY WHICH ARE SUBJECT TO THE CONTROL OF SOCIETY ARE THE STRUCTURE OF PENALTIES BY OFFENSE, THE PROBABILITY OF DETECTION FOR EACH OFFENSE, AND CERTAIN COSTS OF THE CONDUCT OF THE OFFENDING ACTIVITY. IN ADDITION, THE PENALTIES AND CHANCES OF DETECTION AND PUNISHMENT MUST BE INCREASING FUNCTIONS OF THE ENORMITY OF THE OFFENSE. UNDER A STRUCTURE OF RATIONAL ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITIES, EXPECTED PENALTIES INCREASE WITH EXPECTED GAINS TO THE OFFENDER SO THERE IS NO MARGINAL NET GAIN FROM LARGER OFFENSES. THE EXPENDITURES ON PREVENTION AND ENFORCEMENT SHOULD YIELD A DIMINUTION IN OFFENSES, AT THE MARGIN, EQUAL TO THE RETURN UPON THESE RESOURCES IN OTHER AREAS. THE WIDESPREAD FAILURE TO ADOPT RATIONAL CRITERIA OF ENFORCEMENT OF LAWS HAS BEEN OFTEN AND, PERHAPS, USUALLY DUE TO A SIMPLE LACK OF UNDERSTANDING OF THE NEED FOR AND NATURE OF RATIONAL ENFORCEMENT, IN ADDITION TO THE DESIRE OF THE PUBLIC NOT TO ENFORCE THE LAWS.