U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

DILEMMA OF IMPASSE PROCEDURES IN THE PUBLIC SAFETY SERVICES (FROM COLLECTIVE BARGAINING IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR - SELECTED READINGS IN LAW ENFORCEMENT, 1977 BY RICHARD M. AYRES AND THOMAS L. WHEELEN - SEE NCJ-42575)

NCJ Number
42587
Author(s)
M H BOWERS
Date Published
1977
Length
9 pages
Annotation
THE EMERGENCE OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING IN MANY AREAS OF PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT HAS MEANT THAT PROCEDURES OTHER THAN THE STRIKE HAVE HAD TO BE DEVISED FOR RESOLVING LABOR DISPUTES.
Abstract
THREE BASIC TYPES OF IMPASSE PROCEDURES HAVE BEEN USED IN THE PUBLIC SAFETY SERVICES - MEDIATION, FACT-FINDING, AND ARBITRATION. HOWEVER, THERE HAS BEEN A FAILURE TO RECOGNIZE A SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ALTERNATIVES TO STRIKE ACTION PER SE AND SUBSTITUTES FOR THE FUNCTIONS OF THE RIGHT TO STRIKE WHICH ARE AN INTEGRAL PART OF THE BARGAINING PROCESS. MEDIATION AND FACT-FINDING HAVE BEEN THE STRIKE ALTERNATIVES MOST FREQUENTLY EMPLOYED IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR, ALTHOUGH NEITHER HAS BEEN ENTIRELY SATISFACTORY, PREDOMINANTLY BECAUSE THE OUTCOME HAS NOT BEEN FINAL AND BINDING UPON BOTH PARTIES. OF EQUAL SIGNIFICANCE, EACH HAS FAILED IN ITS OWN WAY TO MITIGATE THE EFFECT OF DENIAL OF THE RIGHT TO STRIKE ON THE BARGAINING PROCESS. A SYSTEM OF LEGISLATED ARBITRATION, IN WHICH TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE ARE COLLECTED TO SUPPORT A FINAL AND BILATERALLY BINDING AWARD TERMINATING A DISPUTE, CAN MOST CLOSELY APPROXIMATE THE FUNCTIONS OF A STRIKE IN THE BARGAINING PROCESS. (THE STRIKE SERVES THREE BASIC PURPOSES IN COLLECTIVE BARGAINING: TO GIVE A POWERFUL IMPETUS TO THE PROCESSES OF CONCESSION AND COMPROMISE; TO CREATE A SENSE OF URGENCY PROPELLING THE PARTIES TOWARD A PARTICULAR SOLUTION; AND TO IMPOSE A DIRECT COST OF DISAGREEMENT UPON THE PARTIES.)...ELW

Downloads

No download available

Availability