U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

INDIGENT DEFENSE SYSTEMS ANALYSIS PROJECT - FINAL REPORT

NCJ Number
43542
Author(s)
B LYNCH; K SMITH
Date Published
1976
Length
215 pages
Annotation
A NATIONAL STUDY OF DEFENSE SERVICES FOR INDIGENTS AND OF PLEA-BARGAINING PRACTICES AS THEY RELATE TO INDIGENT DEFENDANTS IS DOCUMENTED.
Abstract
THE STUDY INCLUDED A QUESTIONNAIRE SURVEY OF 601 INDIGENT DEFENSE SYSTEMS (70 PERCENT RESPONSE) AND FIELD VISITS TO 8 SYSTEMS. THE STUDY REPORT OFFERS A DESCRIPTION OF THE STAFFING, OPERATIONS, AND CASELOADS OF THE DEFENSE SYSTEM SURVEYED AND AN ANALYSIS OF PLEA-BARGAINING PRACTICES IN THESE SYSTEMS. THE STUDY CONCLUDES THAT A VARIETY OF STRUCTURES FOR PROVIDING DEFENSE SERVICES TO PERSONS UNABLE TO EMPLOY THEIR OWN ATTORNEYS ARE BEING USED, BUT THAT THERE IS NO AGREEMENT AS TO WHICH STRUCTURE PROVIDES THE BEST DEFENSE SERVICES AT THE LOWEST COST. ALTHOUGH NO ONE AGENCY CHARACTERISTIC WAS FOUND TO ACCOUNT FOR AGENCY-TO-AGENCY VARIATIONS IN GUILTY PLEA RATES, IT WAS FOUND THAT LARGER DEFENSE AGENCIES WITH LARGER CASELOADS AND BIGGER BUDGETS TEND TO HAVE HIGHER GUILTY PLEA RATES. THE STUDY ALSO POINTS TO POSSIBLE EXPLANATIONS FOR THE FACT THAT MOST INDIGENT DEFENSE CLIENTS CHOOSE A GUILTY PLEA DISPOSITION OVER A TRIAL. SUPPORTING DATA AND DETAILS OF METHODOLOGY ARE INCLUDED. (LKM)