U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

NO COMPRENDO - THE NON-ENGLISH-SPEAKING DEFENDANT AND THE CRIMINAL PROCESS

NCJ Number
43602
Journal
Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Volume: 68 Issue: 1 Dated: (MARCH 1977) Pages: 15-30
Author(s)
J B SAFFORD
Date Published
1977
Length
16 pages
Annotation
THE PROBLEMS INHERENT IN ARRESTING, SETTING BAIL FOR, ARRAIGNING, ACCEPTING A PLEA FROM, AND TRYING DEFENDANTS WHO DO NOT UNDERSTAND OR SPEAK ENGLISH ARE EXAMINED, WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO THE SITUATION IN ILLINOIS.
Abstract
A REVIEW OF THE SCOPE OF THE PROBLEM OF THE NON-ENGLISH-SPEAKING DEFENDANT NOTES THAT, ALTHOUGH THE INABILITY TO COPE IN ANY BUT THE MOST CURSORY WAY WITH THE DEMANDS OF THE DOMINANT CULTURE AFFECTS THE NON-ENGLISH-SPEAKING PERSON IN A NUMBER OF AREAS, THE RISKS OF NONCOMPREHENSION ARE HIGHEST IN CONFRONTATIONS WITH THE LAW. A CRITICAL EXAMINATION OF ILLINOIS STATUTES AND COURT DECISIONS REGARDING THE CONSTITUTIONAL QUESTIONS RAISED BY FAILURE TO PROVIDE INTERPRETERS FOR NON-ENGLISH-SPEAKING DEFENDANTS SUGGESTS THAT ILLINOIS IS BEHIND THE FEDERAL COURTS AND THE COURTS OF SOME OTHER STATES IN PROTECTING THE INTERESTS OF THESE DEFENDANTS. ALTHOUGH THE ILLINOIS APPELLATE COURT RECOGNIZES THAT FAILURE TO PROVIDE AN INTERPRETER MIGHT VIOLATE A DEFENDANT'S RIGHTS TO A JURY TRIAL OR TO CONFRONTATION OF WITNESSES, THE COURT CONTINUES TO DEFER TO THE TRIAL COURT'S DISCRETION IN SUCH CASES, THUS DISCOURAGING APPEALS BASED ON THE MATTER OF LANGUAGE INTERPRETATION. IN COOK COUNTY, ILL., THE JUDICIAL PRACTICE OF CALLING UPON THE COURT'S FULL-TIME INTERPRETER WHEN THERE IS ANY INDICATION OF NEED IS DEVELOPING. HOWEVER, UNTIL THE COURT OR LEGISLATURE ESTABLISHES STANDARDS AND PROCEDURES WITH REGARD TO DETERMINING THE NEED FOR AN INTERPRETER AND ASSURING THE QUALITY OF INTERPRETATION, THE NON-ENGLISH-SPEAKING DEFENDANT'S RIGHTS ARE NOT FULLY PROTECTED.