U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

FROM RETRIBUTION TO 'DESERT' - THE EVOLUTION OF CRIMINAL PUNISHMENT

NCJ Number
44328
Journal
Criminology Volume: 15 Issue: 2 Dated: (AUGUST 1977) Pages: 179-192
Author(s)
F R KELLOGG
Date Published
1977
Length
14 pages
Annotation
THE MOVEMENT IN PENOLOGY AWAY FROM REHABILITATION AND TOWARD GREATER CONSISTENCY IN SENTENCING IS EXAMINED, WITH REFERENCE TO THE VIEWS SET FORTH BY THE COMMITTEE FOR THE STUDY OF INCARCERATION.
Abstract
PUNISHMENT CONVENTIONALLY IS EXPLAINED IN TERMS OF A FEW FINITE PURPOSES: DETERRENCE; REHABILITATION; INCAPACITATION; AND RETRIBUTION. THE MOVEMENT TOWARD DETERMINATE SENTENCING AND AWAY FROM REHABILITATION SUGGESTS A RETURN TO THE RETRIBUTIVE TRADITION. HOWEVER, ANALYSIS OF THE PROGRAM AND PHILOSOPHY OF DETERMINATE SENTENCING REVEALS A FUNDAMENTAL BREAK WITH THE RETRIBUTIVE TRADITION OF PUNISHMENT ACCORDING TO GENERIC CATEGORIES OF CONDUCT. ARGUMENTS IN FAVOR OF DETERMINATE SENTENCING ARE CRITICAL OF REHABILITATION AS A GROUND FOR INDIVIDUALIZED DISCRETION, PROPOSING DESERT (I.E., WHAT IS DESERVED BY AN INDIVIDUAL FOUND GUILTY OF WRONGDOING) AS AN ALTERNATIVE BASIS FOR DETERMINING SANCTIONS. THE PHILOSOPHY OF PUNISHMENT HAS SHIFTED GRADUALLY FROM A FOCUS ON VENGEANCE AND EXPIATION TOWARD INDIVIDUALIZED CONSIDERATION OF FACTORS RELEVANT TO FAIRNESS. THE MOVEMENT TOWARD REGULARIZING THE ASSESSMENT OF SUCH FACTORS PLACES PARTICULAR EMPHASIS ON HARM AND CULPABILITY AS MAJOR COMPONENTS OF THE CONCEPT OF SERIOUSNESS OF THE CRIME COMMITTED. THE DETERMINATE SENTENCING MOVEMENT, ALTHOUGH A REACTION TO THE EXCESSES OF DISPARATE SENTENCING, RECOGNIZES THE SEPARATION OF SANCTIONS FROM A STRICT RELATION TO SYMBOLIC CATEGORIES OF CONDUCT AND ATTEMPTS TO REORDER SANCTIONS ACCORDING TO A REGULARIZED BALANCE OF PARTICULAR CIRCUMSTANCES. (AUTHOR ABSTRACT MODIFIED--LKM)

Downloads

No download available

Availability