U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

PENAL PRACTICE IN AMERICA (FROM INTRODUCTION TO CORRECTIONS - SELECTED READINGS, 1978, BY GEORGE G KILLINGER AND PAUL F CROMWELL, JR - SEE NCJ-47802)

NCJ Number
47803
Author(s)
S L BARNES
Date Published
1978
Length
29 pages
Annotation
THE ROLES OF RETRIBUTIVIST AND UTILITARIAN DOCTRINES IN GOVERNING THE HANDLING OF OFFENDERS IN THE PAST AND IN DETERMINING THE PENAL PRACTICES OF THE FUTURE ARE EXAMINED.
Abstract
THE DISCUSSION FOCUSES ON THE MAJOR TRENDS, PERSONS, ORGANIZATIONS, AND PRACTICES THAT HAVE SHAPED THE COURSE OF PENAL PRACTICES IN THE UNITED STATES. THE HISTORICAL REVIEW COVERS THE FOLLOWING PERIODS: THE COLONIAL PERIOD (1682-1790); THE EARLY AMERICAN PERIOD (1790-1830); THE AUBURN AND PENNSYLVANIA ERA (1830-1870); THE REFORMATORY ERA (1870-1900); THE INDUSTRIAL PRISON PERIOD (1900-1935); AND THE CASEWORK PRISON PERIOD (1935-1970). THE HISTORY OF PENOLOGY IN THE UNITED STATES REFLECTS A MIXTURE OF CONFLICTING MOTIVES: HUMANITARIANISM AND THE DESIRE TO REAP UTILITARIAN BENEFITS FROM ITS APPLICATION TO PENAL TECHNIQUES; REVENGE; AND THE NOTION THAT PUNISHMENT REFORMS THE CRIMINAL. PENOLOGY'S OVERRIDING EMPHASIS ON SECURITY AND CUSTODY IS THE LOGICAL RESULT OF THE DOMINANCE OF THE MOTIVE OF REVENGE (RETRIBUTION), WHICH HAS BEEN TRANSLATED INTO CORRECTIONAL POLICIES. RETRIBUTION HAS IMPEDED PENAL PRACTICE THROUGHOUT HISTORY AND HAS NO PLACE IN THE FUTURE. SIGNS THAT RETRIBUTION IS ON THE DECLINE INCLUDE EMPHASIS ON REINTEGRATION, DIVERSION, AND COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT. HOWEVER, HISTORY SUGGESTS THAT TENDENCIES TO RUSH INTO REFORMS MUST BE TEMPERED BY SOUND JUDGMENT AND EMPIRICAL DATA DERIVED FROM RESEARCH. (LKM)