U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

TRIAL JUDGE'S DILEMMA - THE TAKING OF GUILTY PLEAS

NCJ Number
51822
Journal
Court Review Volume: 16 Issue: 3 Dated: (JANUARY/FEBRUARY 1978) Pages: 4-7
Author(s)
D D SCHEPPS
Date Published
1978
Length
4 pages
Annotation
A PRECISE PROCEDURE FOR HEARING GUILTY PLEAS IS SUGGESTED FOR THE COURT IN ORDER TO REDUCE THE GROUNDS FOR APPEALS WHEN THE PLEA IS DENIED.
Abstract
IT IS REPORTED THAT 50 TO 60 PERCENT OF THE POSTCONVICTION PROCEEDINGS HEARD IN THE FEDERAL AND STATE COURTS COME FROM DEFENDANTS WHO HAVE ENTERED GUILTY PLEAS. THE MAKING AND PRESERVING OF A RECORD, PREFERABLY VERBATIM, OF ALL COURT PROCEEDINGS SURROUNDING THE HEARING OF A NEGOTIATED GUILTY PLEA IS RECOMMENDED. IT IS ADVISED THAT THE RECORD SHOULD CONTAIN A COMPLETE STATEMENT OF THE TERMS OF THE AGREEMENT AND THE JUDGE'S REASONS FOR ACCEPTING OR DENYING THE PLEA. THIS FORMAL PROCEDURE IS BELIEVED NECESSARY BECAUSE THE PLEA DISCUSSIONS THEMSELVES ARE USUALLY INFORMAL AND PRACTICALLY UNREVIEWABLE. WHILE IT IS MAINTAINED THE COURT SHOULD NOT PARTICIPATE IN PLEA NEGOTIATIONS, THE COURT SHOULD INQUIRE AS TO THE EXISTENCE OF A NEGOTIATED AGREEMENT WHENEVER A GUILTY PLEA IS ENTERED, WITH A VIEW TOWARD CAREFULLY SCRUTINIZING THE SUBSTANCE OF THE AGREEMENT. IT IS FURTHER SUGGESTED THAT THE COURT, BEFORE ACCEPTING A GUILTY PLEA, SHOULD REQUIRE THE DEFENDANT TO MAKE A DETAILED STATEMENT REGARDING THE OFFENSE TO WHICH HE IS PLEADING GUILTY. SUCH A STATEMENT WOULD ALSO STIPULATE OTHER OFFENSES OF WHICH THE DEFENDANT HAD BEEN EARLIER CONVICTED. SHOULD THE TRIAL JUDGE NOT ACCEPT THE GUILTY PLEA, THIS STATEMENT AND ANY EVIDENCE OBTAINED THROUGH IT WOULD BE INADMISSIBLE AGAINST THE DEFENDANT IN ANY SUBSEQUENT PROSECUTION. A LIST OF REASONS FOR THE COURT NOT TO ACCEPT A GUILTY PLEA IS PRESENTED. SOME JUDICIAL DECISIONS BEARING ON PLEA NEGOTIATIONS ARE BRIEFLY DISCUSSED, AND IMPROPER INDUCEMENTS COMMUNICATED TO THE DEFENDANT FOR THE PURPOSE OF SECURING A GUILTY PLEA ARE IDENTIFIED. (RCB)

Downloads

No download available

Availability