U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

PRACTICAL APPROACH TO CROSS-EXAMINATION

NCJ Number
55375
Journal
Criminal Law Bulletin Volume: 15 Issue: 2 Dated: (MARCH/APRIL 1979) Pages: 117-150
Author(s)
P B BERGMAN
Date Published
1979
Length
34 pages
Annotation
GUIDELINES FOR PLANNING AND CONDUCTING CROSS-EXAMINATIONS, INCLUDING A MODEL FOR USE BY ATTORNEYS IN GAUGING THE RELATIVE RISKS OF ASKING CERTAIN QUESTIONS, ARE PRESENTED.
Abstract
INEFFECTIVE CROSS-EXAMINATION IS ATTRIBUTED TO THREE FACTORS: THE TENDENCY TO VIEW CROSS-EXAMINATION AS AN ART, ATTORNEYS' BELIEF THAT THEY CANNOT REALLY PREPARE FOR CROSS-EXAMINATION, AND POOR UNDERSTANDING OF THE PURPOSES OF CROSS-EXAMINATION. TO ADDRESS THESE PROBLEMS, A PRACTICAL APPROACH TO PRETRIAL PREPARATION FOR CROSS-EXAMINATION IS PRESENTED, TOGETHER WITH TECHNIQUES FOR ASSURING THAT EACH CROSS-EXAMINATION INQUIRY ACCOMPLISHES ITS PURPOSE. FACTORS THAT SHOULD ENTER INTO THE DECISION TO CROSS-EXAMINE ARE DISCUSSED, AS IS THE USE OF LEADING QUESTIONS TO CONTROL TESTIMONY. A CROSS-EXAMINATION MODEL, WHICH PROVIDES A MEANS OF ASSESSING THE RISKS INVOLVED IN ASKING QUESTIONS FOR WHICH THE CROSS-EXAMINING ATTORNEY CANNOT PREDICT WITH CERTAINTY THE WITNESS' ANSWER, IS PRESENTED. THE MODEL DELINEATES AND ILLUSTRATES WITH EXAMPLES THREE CATEGORIES OF QUESTIONS: HIGH, MEDIUM, AND LOW SAFETY. THE DEGREE OF SAFETY DEPENDS ON THE ABILITY OF THE CROSS-EXAMINER TO REFUTE AN UNFAVORABLE ANSWER. FOR INSTANCE, A HIGH-SAFETY QUESTION IS ONE FOR WHICH AN UNFAVORABLE ANSWER COULD BE REFUTED DIRECTLY, PERHAPS BY TESTIMONY FROM A MORE CREDIBLE WITNESS. GUIDELINES FOR USING THE MODEL TO PLAN AND CONDUCT CROSS-EXAMINATION ARE PRESENTED. ATTORNEYS ARE REMINDED THAT IN DECIDING WHETHER TO ASK A QUESTION ON CROSS-EXAMINATION, THEY MUST CONSIDER NOT ONLY THE SAFETY OF THE QUESTION BUT ALSO ITS IMPORTANCE TO THE CASE. (LKM)

Downloads

No download available

Availability