U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

MAGNET PHENOMENA IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE EDUCATION PERSONALITY COMPARISONS BETWEEN ENFORCEMENT AND CORRECTIONS ORIENTED STUDENTS WITH ADDITIONAL COMPARISONS TO FIELD COUNTERPARTS

NCJ Number
56133
Author(s)
T E SULLENBERGER
Date Published
1977
Length
111 pages
Annotation
PERSONALITY DIFFERENCES BETWEEN STUDENT GROUPS AND BETWEEN STUDENTS AND PRACTITIONERS ARE EXPLORED IN A STUDY OF 209 JUNIOR AND SENIOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE STUDENTS AT THE INSTITUTE OF CONTEMPORARY CORRECTIONS IN TEXAS.
Abstract
THE STUDY HAS TWO OJBECTIVES: (1) TO DETERMINE WHETHER CRIMINAL JUSTICE STUDENTS PLANNING CAREERS IN LAW ENFORCEMENT DIFFER IN PERSONALITY FROM CRIMINAL JUSTICE STUDENTS PLANNING CAREERS IN CORRECTIONS AND (2) TO DETERMINE WHETHER STUDENTS DIFFER IN PERSONALITY FROM THEIR FIELD COUNTERPARTS (WORKING POLICE OFFICERS AND CORRECTIONAL SOCIAL WORKERS). ANALYSIS OF STUDENTS' SCORES ON A PERSONALITY TEST SHOWS THAT THE TWO STUDENT GROUPS ARE DISTINCTLY DIFFERENT FROM EACH OTHER. LAW ENFORCEMENT STUDENTS ARE A HIGHLY STABLE, PROSAIC GROUP COMPARED TO CORRECTIONS STUDENTS, WHO ARE LESS STABLE AND MORE AESTHETIC AND IMAGINATIVE. THIS FINDING SUGGESTS THE POTENTIAL FOR DISCORD BETWEEN POLICE AND CORRECTIONAL PERSONNEL. NEITHER STUDENT GROUP IS LIKE ITS FIELD COUNTERPART. HOWEVER, THE STUDENT-PRACTITIONER COMPARISON IS LIMITED BY RELIANCE ON PRACTITIONER PROFILES REPORTED BY THE DEVELOPERS OF THE PERSONALITY TEST. THE FINDINGS ARE DISCUSSED IN THE CONTEXT OF THE 'MAGNET PHENOMENA' CONCEPT--THE IDEA THAT PEOPLE ARE ATTRACTED TO OR REPELLED BY CERTAIN OCCUPATIONS ON THE BASIS OF THEIR PERSONALITIES. SUPPORTING DATA AND A LIST OF REFERENCES ARE PROVIDED. (LKM)