U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

DECRIMINALIZATION AND THE NEED FOR A RATIONAL CRIMINAL POLICY

NCJ Number
64822
Journal
Indian Journal of Criminology Volume: 8 Issue: 1 Dated: (JANUARY 1980) Pages: 3-6
Author(s)
N R M MENON
Date Published
1980
Length
4 pages
Annotation
IT IS ARGUED THAT INDIA SHOULD FOLLOW THE INTERNATIONAL TREND OF DECRIMINALIZING VICTIMLESS CRIMES.
Abstract
AS A RESULT OF INCREASING CRIME RATES AND THE STRAIN THEY PUT ON THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM, DECRIMINALIZATION IN THE FIELD OF PRIVATE MORALITY HAS BEEN SUGGESTED AS A MEANS OF FREEING THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM FOR ITS ESSENTIAL TASKS OF PROTECTING PERSONS AND PROPERTY. IN INDIA, THE NEW PENAL CODE AMENDMENT BILL OF 1972 RECOMMENDS THE DECRIMINALIZATION OF CERTAIN CASES OF SUICIDE AND ABORTION. HOWEVER, IF DECRIMINALIZATION WERE PURSUED AS A DELIBERATE POLICY, AN ADDITIONAL NUMBER OF OFFENSES (E.G., VAGRANCY, JUVENILE DELINQUENCY, AND PROHIBITED SEXUAL BEHAVIOR) MIGHT WARRANT DECRIMINALIZATION. OVERCRIMINALIZATION, IN FACT, CONTRIBUTES TO THE CRIME PROBLEM BY MAKING THE SUPPLY OF ILLEGAL GOODS (NARCOTICS, GAMBLING ETC.) PROFITABLE TO THE INDIVIDUAL CRIMINAL, BY LEADING TO THE ORGANIZATION OF LARGE-SCALE CRIMINAL GROUPS CATERING TO ILLEGAL DEMANDS, AND BY CAUSING PERSONS DEPENDENT ON ILLEGAL GOODS (E.G., DRUG ADDICTS) TO RESORT TO CRIME TO SUPPORT THEIR EXPENSIVE HABIT. OVERCRIMINALIZATION ALSO LEADS TO THE GROWTH OF A CRIMINAL SUBCULTURE INVOLVING HOMOSEXUALS, DRUG ADDICTS, AND PROSTITUTES, AS WELL AS FAR MORE SERIOUS OFFENDERS, DEPLETES POLICE TIME AND MANPOWER OTHERWISE SPENT ON MORE SERIOUS OFFENSES, AND ENCOURAGES BRIBERY AND CORRUPTION IN CASES OF VICTIMLESS CRIME. MANY COUNTRIES, INCLUDING THE U.S.A. AND WEST GERMANY, HAVE BEGUN TO DECRIMINALIZE SOME CASES OF VICTIMLESS CRIME. OF COURSE, THE DECRIMINALIZATION PROCESS IN ONE COUNTRY CANNOT BE MECHANICALLY EXTENDED TO ANOTHER COUNTRY; HOWEVER, EVEN EXTENSIVE NATIONAL RESEARCH LEADING TO THE DECRIMINALIZATION OF PARTICULAR OFFENSES IN INDIA MIGHT IN THE LONG RUN PROVE ECONOMICAL, EFFICIENT, AND SOCIALLY ACCEPTABLE. SEVERAL REFERENCES ARE PROVIDED. (SAJ)

Downloads

No download available

Availability