U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

ARE LEFT-HANDERS LESS VIOLENT?

NCJ Number
65489
Journal
JOURNAL OF YOUTH ADOLESENCE Volume: 9 Issue: 1 Dated: (1980) Pages: 1-9
Author(s)
M J ANDREW
Date Published
1980
Length
8 pages
Annotation
THIS STUDY TESTED WHETHER LEFT-HANDED JUVENILES ARE OVERREPRESENTED AMONG VIOLENT JUVENILE OFFENDERS AND FOUND THAT LEFT-HANDED OFFENDERS SCORED LOWER THAN RIGHT-HANDERS ON THE VIOLENCE SCALE.
Abstract
PREVIOUS STUDIES HAVE FOUND LEFT-HANDERS TO BE OVERREPRESENTED AMONG JUVENILE LEGAL OFFENDERS. A HYPOTHESIS UNDERLYING PAST RESEARCH CAN BE TERMED 'ORGANICITY-CAUSED VIOLENCE,' IN WHICH DYSFUNCTION OF THE LEFT HEMISPHERE HAS BEEN CONNECTED TO DELINQUENCY BY FITZHUGH (1973) AND TO PSYCHOPATHY BY FLOR-HENRY (1978). FURTHER, THIS LINE OF REASONING ARGUES THAT ORGANICITY AND LEFT-HANDEDNESS ARE ASSOCIATED TO A GREATER DEGREE THAN WOULD BE EXPECTED WITHOUT A CAUSAL RELATIONSHIP. ANOTHER HYPOTHESIS INVOLVES A CONSTRUCT TERMED 'MOTOR EXCITABILITY' (THE READINESS TO RESPOND IN MOTORIC TERMS), INVOLVING THE TAPPING TEST, A TEST OF FINGER OSCILLATION SPEED. THIS CONSTRUCT WAS LINKED WITH LEFT-HANDERS WHEN IT WAS DISCOVERED THAT THEY COULD TAP FASTER THAN RIGHT-HANDERS. BOTH THEORIES AGREE IN PREDICTING GREATER VIOLENCE FOR LEFT-HANDED THAN RIGHT-HANDED OFFENDERS. THE SAMPLE FOR THIS STUDY CONSISTED OF ANGLO AND NON-ANGLO MALE AND FEMALE JUVENILE DELINQUENTS FROM BOTH AN INTENSIVE SUPERVISION PROBATION PROGRAM AND A NONINTENSIVE UNIT. THE MEASURE OF VIOLENT CRIME WAS THE VIOLENCE SCALE, A MEASURE OF THE VIOLENCE POTENTIAL OF OFFENSES READ FROM THE LEGAL RECORD. THE UNEXPECTED RESULTS INDICATED THAT LEFT-HANDED OFFENDERS WERE LESS VIOLENT THAN RIGHT-HANDED OFFENDERS, WITH THE DIFFERENCE HOLDING ACROSS THE FOUR SEX-ETHNICITY SUBGROUPINGS. THE VIOLENT SUBGROUP WAS RIGHT-HANDED BOYS, THE LEAST VIOLENT, LEFT-HANDED GIRLS. THE DISCONFIRMATION OF BOTH THEORIES SHOWS THAT MORE RESEARCH IN THE FIELD IS NEEDED. SPECULATIONS ARE OFFERED FOR FUTURE RESEARCH. TABLES AND REFERENCES ARE INCLUDED. (WJR)

Downloads

No download available

Availability