U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

PUBLIC COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE POLICE (FROM EVALUATING ALTERNATIVE LAW-ENFORCEMENT POLICIES, 1979, BY RALPH BAKER AND FRED A MEYER, JR - SEE NCJ-65735)

NCJ Number
65745
Author(s)
G CAIDEN; H HAHN
Date Published
1979
Length
8 pages
Annotation
ALTHOUGH POLICE TRADITIONALLY RESIST OUTSIDE INTERFERENCE, THE PUBLIC HAS A RIGHT TO COMPLAIN; RECOMMENDATIONS ARE MADE FOR NEW CITIZEN COMPLAINT PROCESSES TO REPLACE PRESENT, UNSATISFACTORY ONES.
Abstract
CITIZEN COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE POLICE MAY OFTEN STEM FROM POOR INFORMATION, YET CITIZENS IN A DEMOCRATIC SOCIETY HAVE A RIGHT TO COMPLAIN ABOUT PUBLIC SERVANTS ACTING IN THEIR OFFICIAL CAPACITY. NEVERTHELESS, NO CHEAP, RELIABLE COMPLAINT PROCESS, BENEFICIAL TO BOTH CITIZENS AND POLICE, EXISTS. BY THE NATURE OF ITS WORK, THE POLICE FORCE TENDS TO BE LOYAL TO ITS OWN, CUT OFF FROM THE COMMUNITY, AND RESENTFUL OF OUTSIDE INTERFERENCE. POLICE WILL CLOSELY GUARD THEIR ORGANIZATION'S INDEPENDENCE TO PREVENT THEIR BEING MANIPULATED POLITICALLY. MOREOVER, THE PRESS AND POLITICIANS TEND TO PROTECT POLICE. USUALLY THE POLICE THEMSELVES INVESTIGATE COMPLAINTS AGAINST THEM, BUT SOME DEPARTMENTS LACK PROCEDURES AND OTHERS PENALIZE COMPLAINANTS. ALTHOUGH THE POLICE OFTEN DO NOT TAKE CITIZENS' COMPLAINTS SERIOUSLY, CITIZENS DO NOT USUALLY COMPLAIN WITHOUT REASON. MORE EFFECTIVE COMPLAINT-HANDLING IS THUS NEEDED. TO COMPROMISE WITH POLICE RESISTANCE TO OUTSIDE REVIEW, AN OMBUDSMAN OR SPECIAL OFFICE SHOULD BE ESTABLISHED TO INVESTIGATE COMPLAINTS BUT WITHOUT RECOMMENDATION OR DISCIPLINARY POWERS. IT IS SUGGESTED THAT INCIDENTS OF POLICE'S SHOOTING BY POLICE BE AUTOMATICALLY INVESTIGATED BY THE COMPLAINT-HANDLING BODY. (PAP)