U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

CIVIL RIGHTS OF THE INSTITUTIONALIZED - REPORT OF THE COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY, UNITED STATES SENATE ON S 10 TOGETHER WITH MINORITY AND ADDITIONAL VIEWS

NCJ Number
67424
Author(s)
ANON
Date Published
1979
Length
71 pages
Annotation
THE REPORT PROVIDES THE HISTORY AND SUPPORTIVE REASONS FOR A SENATE BILL GIVING THE UNITED STATES ATTORNEY GENERAL THE AUTHORITY TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS OF INSTITUTIONALIZED PERSONS.
Abstract
SINCE 1971, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL HAS PARTICIPATED IN SEVERAL CIVIL ACTIONS TO REDRESS WIDESPREAD VIOLATIONS OF CONSTITUTIONAL AND FEDERAL STATUTORY RIGHTS OF PERSONS LIVING IN STATE INSTITUTIONS. IN EVERY SUIT THE COURTS HAVE UPHELD THE PLAINTIFF'S RIGHTS, AND AS A RESULT LIVING CONDITIONS HAVE IMPROVED FOR THE MENTALLY-ILL AND RETARDED IN STATE HOSPITALS AND ADULT AND JUVENILE PRISONERS. PERSONS UNNECESSARILY OR IMPROPERLY COMMITTED TO INSTITUTIONS HAVE BEEN RELEASED OR REMOVED TO COMMUNITY RESIDENCES. THIS LEGISLATION HAS BEEN PROPOSED BECAUSE THE PROGRESS OF THE FEDERAL LITIGATION PROGRAM IS THREATENED BY FEDERAL COURT DECISIONS IN MARYLAND AND MONTANA WHICH HAVE RULED THAT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL LACKED EXPRESS AUTHORITY TO INITIATE CIVIL ACTIONS CHALLENGING CONDITIONS IN STATE FACILITIES FOR THE MENTALLY RETARDED. THE PROPOSED BILL DOES NOT CREATE ANY NEW RIGHTS, BUT CODIFIES THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S AUTHORITY TO INITIATE AND INTERVENE IN SUITS TO REDRESS SERIOUS AND PERVASIVE PATTERNS OF INSTITUTIONAL ABUSE. THE TEXT OF THE BILL IS FOLLOWED BY A DETAILED DISCUSSION OF LEGISLATIVE HISTORY, ACTIVITIES OF THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT, AND REASONS FOR THE LAW SUCH AS INADEQUACY OF PRIVATE SOURCES TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS OF THE INSTITUTIONALIZED. THE BILL'S CONSTITUTIONALITY AND STANDARDS FOR FILING SUITS ARE EXAMINED ALONG WITH FEDERAL PRISON COMPLIANCE. A SECTION-BY-SECTION ANALYSIS OF THE PROVISIONS IS ALSO PRESENTED. THE COMMITTEE DOES NOT ANTICIPATE ANY COST INCREASES OR IMPACT ON PERSONAL PRIVACY OF AFFECTED INDIVIDUALS AS A RESULT OF THE BILL. THE APPENDIXES CONTAIN COMMENTS FROM THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT AND THE CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE, A MEMO FROM THE AMERICAN LAW DIVISION OF THE CONGRESSIONAL RESEARCH SERVICE, AND OPPOSING VIEWS OF FOUR SENATORS. (MJM)