U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Anomie - Two Theories of Prison Riots

NCJ Number
89166
Journal
Canadian Journal of Criminology Volume: 25 Issue: 2 Dated: (April 1983) Pages: 173-190
Author(s)
F J Desroches
Date Published
1983
Length
18 pages
Annotation
Although Robert Merton's theory of anomie can be used to explain some prison riots, Durkheim's appears to have greater validity in accounting for the violent, unpredictable, and undirected nature of most riots.
Abstract
Robert Merton's deviance theory posits that anomie arises from a socially structured situation in which a lower socioeconomic class, frustrated in legitimately attaining financial goals, turns to illegitimate or innovative means. With reference to his typology of individual adaptations, it could be hypothesized that most inmates are retreatist, attempting to avoid trouble in prison. A few, however, try to adapt by attempting to thwart prison restrictions through the use of illegitimate opportunity structures, and, if frustrated, are placed in a situation of anomie. The result is instigation of a riot to obtain goals through illegitimate means. However, this theory does not explain why, in many incidents, rioters have no specific demands, inmates who act as spokesmen for rioting prisoners are often not the instigators, and riots usually do not begin as organized and planned movements but start spontaneously and unpredictably, with the power structure and direction emerging as the riot is in process. A list of demands appears to often legitimize the behavior rather than cause it, and many riots are violent and slow to defuse even if the administration accedes to inmates' demands. Durkheim's theory of anomie is a better explanation of riot behavior. Applied to prison riots, it can be used to theorize that any change in administration and organization of the prison (positive or negative) can disrupt the equilibrium and lead to changes in inmates' aspirations and expectations that are not likely to be fulfilled. From this perspective, a prison riot appears to be an emotional reaction resulting from moral indignation. This not only explains the violent nature of many riots, but the fact that the institution of reforms is not preventive. It also helps explain why riots often are unplanned and happen in spurts since changes are often exacted in response to recent riots. Forty-three references are included.

Downloads

No download available

Availability