U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Videotaped Misdemeanor First Appearances - Fairness From the Defendant's Perspective (From Justice and the Media, P 305-320, 1984, Ray Surette, ed. - See NCJ-95768)

NCJ Number
95784
Author(s)
R Surette; W C Terry
Date Published
1984
Length
16 pages
Annotation
The use of video technologies in the courtroom does not appear to have a significant effect upon the defendant's perceptions of the courtroom, of fairness, or of the ability to argue the case, ask questions, talk to judges and lawyers, and enter pleas.
Abstract
However, the use of video affects some individuals' perceptions. Study data came from almost 400 defendants in Dade County (Florida) who were making first appearances for misdemeanors. Closed circuit television was used for some of these appearances; the rest had traditional hearings. The video and nonvideo groups were similar in age, gender, education, employment, ethnic distribution, sentence, and number of charged offenses. However, the nonvideo group had fewer prior court appearances and lower average incomes than the video group. Most defendants felt that the courts had treated them fairly, although a large minority felt that the courts had failed to treat them in a fair manner. Case dispositions affected the perceptions of fairness, as did the number of prior court appearances. Attitudes were more strongly influenced by racial and ethnic group membership, case outcomes, and number of prior hearings than by the use of video equipment. Another defendant population might have produced different results. Data tables and a list of 29 references are supplied.