U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

JUVENILE JUSTICE - NEW YORK'S ACT IS HARD TO FOLLOW

NCJ Number
39406
Journal
Trial Volume: 13 Issue: 2 Dated: (FEBRUARY 1977) Pages: 28-29,32-35
Author(s)
F COHEN
Date Published
1977
Length
6 pages
Annotation
AN EXAMINATION AND CRITIQUE OF THE NEW YORK STATE JUVENILE JUSTICE REFORM ACT OF 1976, WITH SUGGESTIONS FOR REFORMS IN THE CLASSIFICATION, DISPOSITION, AND TREATMENT OF JUVENILES.
Abstract
THE AUTHOR CLAIMS THAT THE NEW JUVENILE JUSTICE REFORM ACT (JJRA) SEEKS TO COMBINE THE PUNISHMENT AND MEDICAL MODELS FOR HANDLING OF JUVENILES. THE JJRA CALLS FOR POSSIBLE SEVEN-YEAR TERMS OF SECURE CONFINEMENT OF SERIOUS JUVENILE OFFENDERS, WHILE PROVIDING A REQUIREMENT OF A DIAGNOSTIC ASSESSMENT BEFORE A JUDGE CAN IMPOSE A RESTRICTIVE PLACEMENT AND A REQUIREMENT FOR INDIVIDUAL TREATMENT PLANS FOR EACH JUVENILE. SPECIFIC PROVISIONS AND PROCEDURES SET FORTH IN THE JJRA ARE EXAMINED AND CRITICIZED. FOR EXAMPLE, THE AUTHOR STATES THAT THE LAW VACILLATES BETWEEN A SEARCH FOR INDIVIDUAL PATHOLOGY AND THE VIEW THAT SERIOUS OFFENSES BY JUVENILES WITH A RECORD SHOULD RECEIVE A MORE SERIOUS DISPOSITION THAN OTHER JUVENILES. HE CLAIMS THAT THE JJRA IS LENGTHY, COMPLICATED, AND POORLY DRAFTED, AND THAT IT DOES NOT ADEQUATELY MEET THE PROBLEMS IT ATTEMPTS TO DEAL WITH. FINALLY, THE AUTHOR PROPOSES SEVERAL REFORMS, INCLUDING CREATION OF A LEGAL CATEGORY OF 'JUVENILE OFFENDER' TO COVER JUVENILES ENGAGING IN CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR, USE OF DETERMINATE DISPOSITIONS FOR JUVENILES, CREATION OF A RIGHT TO SERVICES FOR JUVENILES, AND REMOVAL OF STATUS OFFENDERS FROM THE JUVENILE COURT'S JURISDICTION.

Downloads

No download available

Availability