U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

GOAL SETTING, EVALUATION APPREHENSION AND SOCIAL CUES AS DETERMINANTS OF JOB PERFORMANCE AND JOB SATISFACTION

NCJ Number
54208
Author(s)
S E WHITE; T R MITCHELL; C H BELL
Date Published
1977
Length
29 pages
Annotation
THE EFFECTS OF A GOAL STRUCTURE FOR TASK PERFORMANCE ARE COMPARED TO EVALUATION APPREHENSION AND SOCIAL CUES AS ALTERNATIVE EXPLANATIONS FOR PRODUCTIVITY LEVELS AND JOB SATISFACTION.
Abstract
FOLLOWING A REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE THAT DEVELOPS THE THEORY OF GOAL SETTING AS AN INDEPENDENT VARIABLE IN MOTIVATING TASK PERFORMANCE, THE METHODOLOGY FOR TESTING THIS THEORY BY COMPARING IT WITH THE EFFECTS OF OTHER INDEPENDENT VARIABLES THOUGHT TO INFLUENCE JOB PERFORMANCE IS DESCRIBED. EXPERIMENTAL SUBJECTS INCLUDED 104 UNDERGRADUATE BUSINESS STUDENTS RECRUITED TO PERFORM A SIMULATED CLERICAL TASK IN A REALISTIC WORK ENVIRONMENT. THE EXPERIMENTAL NATURE OF THE JOB STRUCTURE WAS NOT KNOWN TO THE PARTICIPANTS, WHO WERE ASSIGNED RANDOMLY TO A NUMBER OF EXPERIMENTAL GROUPS TO TEST THE EFFECTS OF THE VARIABLES. SOME SUBJECTS WERE ASSIGNED A PRECISE GOAL TO BE ACHIEVED WITHIN A GIVEN TIME FRAME, WHILE OTHERS WERE TOLD THAT THEIR PERFORMANCES WOULD BE EVALUATED IN RELATIONSHIP TO ONE ANOTHER. A CONTROL GROUP RECEIVED NEITHER OF THESE MOTIVATIONAL PLOYS. IN ADDITION, CONFEDERATES WERE ASSIGNED TO EACH GROUP TO PROVIDE SCRIPTED SOCIAL CUES CATEGORIZED AS POSITIVE, NEGATIVE, AND NEUTRAL IN TERMS OF PEER COMMENTS ABOUT JOB SATISFACTION AND PRODUCTIVITY. A QUESTIONNAIRE WAS ADMINISTERED TO EACH SUBJECT FOLLOWING THE JOB PERFORMANCE TO DETERMINE JOB SATISFACTION LEVEL. RESULTS SHOWED THE FOLLOWING: SUBJECTS WITH ASSIGNED GOALS PRODUCED MORE THAN THOSE WITHOUT ASSIGNED GOALS; SUBJECTS WITH HIGH EVALUATION AWARENESS PRODUCED MORE THAN THOSE WITH LOW EVALUATION AWARENESS; AND SUBJECTS RECEIVING POSITIVE SOCIAL CUES PRODUCED. MORE THAN THOSE RECEIVING NEGATIVE SOCIAL CUES. WHILE THE THREE VARIABLES SHOWED NO DIRECT EFFECTS ON OVERALL JOB SATISFACTION, THERE WERE SOME EFFECTS ON THE MEASURES OF JOB PRESSURE, BOREDOM, AND PERFORMANCE SATISFACTION. GOAL SETTING INCREASED BOTH PERCEIVED JOB PRESSURE AND SATISFACTION WITH ONE'S PERFORMANCE, WHILE POSITIVE SOCIAL CUES INCREASED PERCEIVED JOB PRESSURE AND DECREASED BOREDOM WHEN COMPARED TO NEUTRAL AND NEGATIVE SOCIAL CUES.