U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Restitution/Community Service - The Legal Issues (From Restitution Programs in Juvenile and Family Court, 1982, Tape R-10 - See NCJ-91403)

NCJ Number
91415
Author(s)
J Tolan; S Bilchick
Date Published
1982
Length
0 pages
Annotation
This examination of the legal issues involved in the use of restitution programs for juveniles reviews case law bearing upon the rights of due process and equal protection.
Abstract
In examining the legal issues related to restitution, it is concluded that there is no constitutional barrier to restitution per se, but its application must conform to certain constitutional requirements. In using restitution as a form of court diversion, issues of due process arise. It is advised that the juvenile must make a knowing and intelligent choice in waiving the right to a court hearing in favor of entrance into a preadjudication restitution program. This should involve the juvenile's consultation with parents and ideally an attorney. Further, there must be probable cause for an arrest and prosecution before the diversion option is offered. Equal protection issues are advised to require the setting of written policy by which all persons considered for restitution are to be processed. In cases of noncompliance, conditions for violation must be specified either in the diversion order or the court order so as to avoid successful challenges to due process. Equal protection is also advised to require that precise and fair means for setting restitution amounts be instituted and that persons selected for restitution programs not be characterized by inability to pay fines or victim compensation.