U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

POLICY AND IMPLEMENTATION OF JUVENILE JUSTICE - A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NEW YORK CITY (NY) AND BUENOS AIRES

NCJ Number
51237
Author(s)
J B ROMM
Date Published
1976
Length
241 pages
Annotation
PROCEDURES FOR HANDLING JUVENILES ACCUSED OF CRIME, CHILD CARE PROVISIONS, AND THE DEFINITION AND TREATMENT OF STATUS OFFENDERS ARE CONTRASTED FOR FAMILY COURT OF NEW YORK CITY AND CORRECCIONALES OF BUENOS AIRES.
Abstract
THE BACKGROUND PORTION OF THE STUDY CONTRASTS THE HISTORY AND TRADITIONS OF THE UNITED STATES AND ARGENTINA, THEN POINTS OUT THE SIMILARITIES BETWEEN NEW YORK AND BUENOS AIRES. BOTH ARE LARGE, MODERN CITIES WITH LARGE NUMBERS OF EUROPEAN IMMIGRANTS, SLUM AREAS, AND CRIME PROBLEMS. THE HANDLING OF JUVENILE DELINQUENTS AND JUVENILE STATUS OFFENDERS IS THEN EXAMINED FOR EACH CITY, WITH EMPHASIS ON YOUNG PERSONS CONVICTED OF MINOR CRIMES AND STATUS OFFENDERS. ARGENTINA HAS A CATEGORY OF 'MALA CONDUCTA' CHILDREN COMPARABLE TO NEW YORK'S 'PERSONS IN NEED OF SUPERVISION.' DETAILED ANALYSIS IS GIVEN OF SUCH CASES IN BOTH COURTS. IN EACH COUNTRY THESE CHILDREN ARE GENERALLY POOR, FROM DISORGANIZED FAMILIES, AND SUFFERING FROM SEVERE EMOTIONAL PROBLEMS. IN BOTH CITIES THERE ARE INSUFFICIENT SOCIAL WORKERS AND AGENCIES TO HANDLE THE FLOOD OF SUCH CHILDREN. IN NEW YORK THE COURT MORE FREQUENTLY REMOVED THE CHILD FROM THE HOME; IN BUENOS AIRES THERE WERE FEWER PLACES THE CHILD COULD BE SENT. IT IS CONCLUDED THAT MODERN NATIONS ARE GOING TO BE FACED WITH THE PROBLEM OF CHILDREN IN URBAN AREAS NEEDING SUPERVISION AND THAT TREATMENT AND ADEQUATE FACILITIES MUST BE PROVIDED. TABLES PRESENTING STUDY DATA ARE QUITE DETAILED. THE STUDY QUESTIONNAIRES AND A BIBLIOGRAPHY ARE APPENDED. (GLR)