U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

CASE AND COMMENT - SENTENCE

NCJ Number
52472
Journal
Criminal Law Review Dated: (JUNE 1976) Pages: 387-392
Author(s)
W GREENWOOD; D A THOMAS; J C SMITH
Date Published
1976
Length
6 pages
Annotation
SIX BRITISH CASE STUDIES ARE PRESENTED AND THE SENTENCES IMPOSED IN EACH ARE EXAMINED. THEY COVER BORSTAL ORDERS, COMPENSATION FOR STOLEN GOODS, PSYCHOTIC OFFENDERS, A TRADE MISREPRESENTATION CASE, AND DETERRENT SENTENCES.
Abstract
EACH CASE CONTAINS A BRIEF STATEMENT OF THE FACTS, THE SENTENCE IMPOSED, THE JUDGE'S REASONING, AND A COMMENTARY WHICH CITES APPLICABLE ENGLISH LAW. THE FIRST CASE CONCERNS A SENTENCE WHICH COMBINES BORSTAL (REHABILITATIVE) TRAINING WITH A DEPORTATION ORDER; THE SECOND INVOLVES COMPENSATION FOR STOLEN PROPERTY WHEN THE PROPERTY WAS RETURNED UNDAMAGED; AND THE THIRD INVOLVES THE IMPOSITION OF AN EXTENDED SENTENCE FOR A CRIME COMMITTED WHILE A FELON WAS ON PROBATION. IT ADDRESSES THE QUESTION OF WHEN A SENTENCE ACTUALLY ENDS: THE DATE THE PRISONER IS RELEASED ON PROBATION, OR THE DATE ON WHICH THE FULL SENTENCE WOULD HAVE EXPIRED. IN THE TRADE DECEPTION CASE THE PRECEDENT IS ESTABLISHED THAT A JUDGE WHO HAS AN ADVERSE OPINION OF A DEFENDANT WHICH MAY COME INTO PLAY DURING THE SENTENCING MUST MAKE THIS ADVERSE OPINION KNOWN TO THE DEFENSE SO THAT THE ACCUSED HAS A CHANCE TO REBUT. THE PSYCHOPATHIC OFFENDER CASE AFFIRMS THAT THE COURTS DO NOT HAVE AN OBLIGATION TO SENTENCE A PERSON TO A SEVERE TERM FOR A MINOR OFFENSE JUST TO 'KEEP THE DEFENDANT OUT OF TROUBLE FOR A WHILE.' IT IS MAINTAINED THAT MENTAL COMMITMENTS ARE THE PROVINCE OF THE CIVIL COURTS AND THE HEALTH AUTHORITIES. THE FINAL CASE UPHOLDS A SEVERE DETERRENT SENTENCE FOR A JUVENILE CONVICTED OF SEVERAL PREVIOUS FELONIES. THE TEXTS CONTAINS CASE CITATIONS. (GLR)