U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Utility of Drug Testing in the Assessment of Defendant Risk at the Pretrial Release Decision

NCJ Number
124017
Author(s)
J S Goldkamp; M R Gottfredson; D Weiland
Date Published
1988
Length
186 pages
Annotation
Recent research has hypothesized that because large proportions of arrestees test positively for drugs of abuse as they enter the criminal process, evidence of drug use ought to be considered a significant predictor of crime during the pretrial release period.
Abstract
A study in the District of Columbia showed a significant relationship between positive urinalysis results at the bail stage and subsequent criminality or flight by defendants during pretrial release. When used as a condition of release, the D.C. program has been successful in increasing the likelihood of appearance for court dates and decreasing further crime among releasees. Several laws requiring testing have been established throughout the nation, and a number of research studies have been undertaken in this area. A study conducted in Dade County, Florida found that, while drug testing results can play a role in developing a model for pretrial decisionmaking, this information alone is not sufficient; multivariate models can be generated without such information and be just as useful. The weak relationship between drug test results and defendant pretrial outcomes should not divert attention, however, from the important finding that more than 80 percent of all felony defendants entering the criminal process in Dade County were apparently using controlled substances at the time of their arrest. In fact, it is possible to construct a classification system based the prediction of likely drug use that builds on the kind of information currently available from pretrial services in advance of the bail decision. Such a system would be based on level of drug use, rather than on drug testing, and would likely be as useful in pretrial decisionmaking as an actual drug testing program. 46 references, 28 tables, 51 figures.