U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Criminal Women and Criminal Justice: The Limits to, and Potential of, Feminist and Left Realist Perspectives (From Criminological Perspectives: A Reader, P 475-483, 1996, John Muncie, Eugene McLaughlin, and Mary Langan, eds. -- See NCJ- 161531)

NCJ Number
161555
Author(s)
P Carlen
Date Published
1996
Length
9 pages
Annotation
After critiquing left realism radical criminology and the concepts of some feminist scholars regarding criminology, this essay proposes a feminist realist criminological agenda.
Abstract
After identifying the strengths of left realist criminology, the author criticizes it for its positivistic, essentializing, and deterministic tendencies. She is also concerned about the theoretical and political implications of the perspectives advocated by feminists such as Smart and Cain. Her criticism of these perspectives focuses on what she describes as their overly theoretical, separatist, and gendercentric tendencies. The latter part of the essay presents the author's feminist realist criminological agenda that involves the deconstruction and theory development of the problematic relation between women and crime and the development of policies and campaigns that aim to right some of the wrongs encountered by women offenders in the criminal justice and penal systems. The agenda consists of academic activities and campaigning and policy tasks. The latter agenda focuses on fundamental aims, general strategies, short- term achievable goals for the relief of women in the criminal justice and penal systems, and long-term programs that are not achievable under current political conditions. Overall, the author suggests that it is crucial and possible for feminists to continue to work within as well as against criminology. 23 references

Downloads

No download available

Availability