U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

New Paradigm for Understanding Violence?: Testing the Limits of Lonnie Athens's Theory

NCJ Number
203317
Journal
British Journal of Criminology Volume: 43 Issue: 4 Dated: Autumn 2003 Pages: 750-771
Author(s)
Ian O'Donnell
Date Published
2003
Length
22 pages
Annotation
This article critiques the "violentization theory" of Lonnie Athens, which reframes traditional questions about violence as a process, drawing on source material not usually included in criminological research.
Abstract
Athens' theory of "violentization" stems from a series of interviews with 58 inmates in 5 penal institutions in 2 U.S. States during the early 1970's. Approximately half of the inmates had been convicted of homicide, with the remainder serving time for rape or aggravated assault. All but 11 of the inmates were males. The prison interviews were supplemented by accounts of violence that Athens himself had witnessed, primarily during his own childhood and adolescence. These included a murder, an attempted rape, and a man being stabbed in the eyes with a can opener. Athens views violent behavior as a developmental process that includes four stages: brutalization, defiance, dominance engagement, and virulency. Brutalization has three elements: violent subjugation, personal "horrification," and violent coaching. Defiance occurs as the victim resolves never to let himself/herself be subjugated or abused again. Dominance engagement occurs as those who have resolved defiance inflict "grievous injuries" on people they perceive as potential abusers. "Virulency" occurs as the person gains a reputation for violence, people become submissive under his intimidation, and he makes a firm resolution to attack or kill if provoked. The theory outlined by Athens purports to account for every person who becomes violent. This article argues, however, that there are other pathways to violence, and not all of those who commit serious acts of violence have undergone Athen's four stages of "violentization." Although acknowledging that Athen's theory may apply to the etiology of some violent behavioral patterns, this article identifies significant manifestations of violence that may arise from other pathways. Other pathways are discussed for the following types of violence: hand-to-hand combat in modern warfare, the bureaucratic underpinnings of genocide, religious fanaticism, dueling, sado-masochism, and selective infanticide. 88 references

Downloads

No download available

Availability