U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Neck Injuries Caused by Automatic Two-Point Seat Belts: An Analysis of Four Cases

NCJ Number
208581
Journal
Journal of Forensic Sciences Volume: 50 Issue: 1 Dated: January 2005 Pages: 159-163
Author(s)
Daniel J. Spitz M.D.; Paul C. Prator M.D.; James E. Stratton B.A.; Luis Labiste M.D.; Jeffrey S. Augenstein M.D.; Jeffery Mackinnon; Jerry Phillips; Martin Singer; Elana Perdeck B.S.; Stacy Chimento B.S.
Date Published
January 2005
Length
5 pages
Annotation
This paper presents four case studies that involved fatal neck injuries due to the improper use of an automatic two-point seat-belt shoulder harness without a manual lap restraint.
Abstract
In the first case, the driver of the case vehicle hit another car in such a way that the driver's door was forced open and the driver propelled toward the resulting opening. Because the driver was wearing only the two-point shoulder harness, his neck and upper torso were anchored by the restraint as his unrestrained hips and lower extremities continued to move. The momentum of his lower body against his restrained neck led to decapitation. In the second case, the crash involved a frontal crash in which the occupant's lower body, unanchored without a manual lap belt, moved forward with terrific force while the automatic two-point shoulder harness restrained her at the neck and chin, causing a near complete decapitation. The third case involved a similar front end crash in which the vehicle's occupant was unrestrained by a lap belt but restrained by an automatic two-point shoulder harness, causing her trachea to be transected through the cricoid cartilage, along with injury to the second cervical vertebra. In the fourth case, the right front occupant was ejected from the vehicle in the course of the vehicle's roll-over. As she was being ejected, the shoulder restraint pressed against her neck with sufficient force to cause fatal injuries. Based on these and other case studies, the authors advise that the use of an automatic two-point shoulder harness without concurrent use of a lap belt may be associated with severe neck trauma that can involve cervical spine fractures and rarely decapitation. 4 figures and 26 references