U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Key to the Gatekeepers: Passive Consent and Other Ethical Issues Surrounding the Rights of Children To Speak on Issues That Concern Them

NCJ Number
216317
Journal
Child Abuse & Neglect Volume: 30 Issue: 9 Dated: September 2006 Pages: 979-989
Author(s)
Janis Carroll-Lind; James W. Chapman; Janet Gregory; Gabrielle Maxwell
Date Published
September 2006
Length
11 pages
Annotation
The authors describe their approach in gaining consent for direct research with children in New Zealand regarding self-reports on their views and experiences of violence at home and at school.
Abstract
Specifically, they describe the procedures for resolving ethical concerns about child research with the university ethics committee, principals of the schools where the survey was conducted, school governing boards, teachers, parents, and the children themselves. The authors ultimately adopted passive consent procedures to overcome ethical issues in a national survey of New Zealand elementary-school children's experiences of violence. Although the paper focuses on the passive consent procedures rather than survey findings, aspects of the sampling and research methods are described to set the context for the study. Passive consent requires only parents who do not give their permission for their child to participate in the survey to sign and return the consent form. Parents who do not return the form are deemed to have given passive consent. Seeking active consent from parents and caregivers may have denied some children their right to choose to participate. This paper describes the three-stage consent process used to gain access to the children for their self reports. At all points, the consent process offered schools, parents, and children the option to decline participation. Issues discussed are confidentiality, truthfulness, minimizing harm and deception, and social sensitivity. Another methodological issue discussed is the importance of using words the children can understand in defining physical, emotional, and sexual violence. The children who participated in the pilot study helped in framing the definitions to fit the youth culture. 35 references