U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

POLITICAL FEASIBILITY OF PUNISHMENT (FROM JUSTICE AND PUNISHMENT, 1977, BY J.B. CEDERBLOM AND WILLIAM L. BLIZEK SEE NCJ-43084)

NCJ Number
43087
Author(s)
J Q WILSON
Date Published
1977
Length
17 pages
Annotation
LACK OF PUBLIC AGREEMENT ABOUT PROPER TREATMENT OF CRIMINAL OFFENDERS, LACK OF RESOURCES, AND THE INERTIA OF INSTITUTIONS ARE BLAMED FOR THE INCONSISTENCIES IN THE U.S. JUSTICE SYSTEM.
Abstract
AT PRESENT, THE CRIMINAL APPREHENSION, TRIAL, AND PUNISHMENT SYSTEM IN THE UNITED STATES IS CAUGHT IN A DEBATE BETWEEN LIBERALS, WHO FEEL THAT FIRST OFFENDERS SHOULD RECEIVE MINIMAL CONTACT WITH THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM LEST THEY BE FORCED INTO A LIFE OF CRIME, AND THOSE WHO FEEL THAT SWIFT AND JUST RETRIBUTION IS ESSENTIAL TO CRIME DETERRENCE. LACK OF PHYSICAL FACILITIES ALSO HAMPERS THE SYSTEM. PRESENT FACILITIES ARE TOO LARGE TO BE SAFE. TO OFFER ANY ATTEMPT AT JUSTICE, MANY SMALL FACILITIES, EACH DESIGNED TO HOUSE CERTAIN TYPES OF OFFENDERS, ARE NEEDED. CITIZENS ARE NOT OPPOSED TO BUILDING PRISONS: THEY ARE OPPOSED TO SPENDING ANY MORE TAX MONEY ON THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM. JUDGES AND THOSE IN AUTHORITY ALSO HINDER REFORM BECAUSE THEIR ATTITUDES TEND TO BE TRADITIONAL. AS ONE MONITORS CONTEMPORARY DISCUSSIONS OF PUNISHMENT, ONE IS STRUCK BY THE EXTENT TO WHICH SCHOLARS, PUBLIC OFFICIALS, POLICE, AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICIALS ARE MOVING INTO AGREEMENT, WHILE LARGE SEGMENTS OF THE LAW PROFESSION AND THE BENCH ARE ABSENT FROM THE CONSENSUS. THESE INTELLECTUAL AND POLITICAL CONSIDERATIONS HELP EXPLAIN WHY, IN A NATION BESET WITH CRIME IN WHICH A DOMINANT CONCERN OF THE MAJORITY OF CITIZENS IS FEAR OF VICTIMIZATION, LITTLE HAPPENS THAT MIGHT AFFECT CRIME RATES OR AT LEAST SATISFY THE POPULAR DESIRE FOR JUSTICE.

Downloads

No download available

Availability