U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

MYTH OF THE BATTERED CHILD SYNDROME - A COMPASSIONATE MEDICAL VIEW OF THE PROTECTION OF CHILDREN (FROM NATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON CHILD ABUSE, 1972 - SEE NCJ-09640)

NCJ Number
48641
Author(s)
E H NEWBERGER
Date Published
1972
Length
6 pages
Annotation
IN AN EFFORT TO UNDERSCORE A COMPASSIONATE VIEW LIKELY TO LEAD TO AN EFFECTIVE, COORDINATED INTERVENTION, CHILD ABUSE IS DISCUSSED AS A SYMPTOM OF DISTRESS IN A COMPLEX FAMILY ECOSYSTEM CONTAINING MANY INTERACTIVE VARIABLES.
Abstract
THE MYTH OF THE BATTERED CHILD SYNDROME IS ACCEPTED BY MANY IN THE FIELD AND IT IS REFLECTED IN SOME CHILD ABUSE LEGISLATION THAT HOLDS THAT THE ROOT CAUSE OF CHILD ABUSE IS CRUEL PARENTS WHO CHOOSE INTENTIONALLY TO ABUSE THEIR CHILDREN. THIS VIEW IS TOO NARROW AND DESIGNED TO REDUCE THE INCIDENCE OF CHILD ABUSE BY CORRECTING THE CONDITIONS THAT SPAWN IT. THE CAUSES OF CHILD ABUSE ARE A COMPLEX INTERWEAVING OF DEBILITATING SOCIOECONOMIC CONDITIONS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO A SEVERE LIMITATION IN THE CAPABILITY OF PARENTS TO PROVIDE THEIR CHILDREN WITH PROPER EMOTIONAL AND PHYSICAL NOURISHMENT. ABUSIVE BEHAVIOR BY PARENTS IS THEREFORE VIEWED AS A SYMPTOM OF DEEPER CAUSES CREATING INCAPACITATING STRESS WITH THE FAMILY SETTING. EXAMPLES OF THE APPLICATION OF THIS VIEW TO THE TREATMENT OF ABUSE ARE PROVIDED. ONE EXAMPLE INVOLVES THE CREATION OF AN INTERAGENCY, MULTIDISCIPLINARY CONSULTATION GROUP WHICH MEETS WEEKLY AT A HOSPITAL TO EXPLORE THE NEEDS OF THE CHILDREN BEARING THE PHYSICAL SYMPTOMS OF SEVERE FAMILY DISTRESS. THIS GROUP ATTEMPTS TO HELP FAMILIES BY LOCATING SERVICES WHICH CAN IMPROVE THE FAMILIES ABILITY TO FUNCTION POSITIVELY. THESE SERVICES INCLUDE MEDICAL, DENTAL, SOCIAL SERVICES, AS WELL AS LEGAL HELP, CHILD CARE, HOMEMAKER SERVICES, AND PSYCHIATRIC TREATMENT. INADEQUATE ATTEMPTS TO DEAL WITH CIRCUMSTANCES SPAWNING CHILD ABUSE ARE CITED, PARTICULARLY IN THE ARENA OF WELFARE SERVICES. REFERENCES ARE FOOTNOTED. (RCB)