U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

INCARCERATION - BENEFITS AND DRAWBACKS (FROM INCARCERATION - BENEFITS AND DRAWBACKS, 1977, BY P ECK AND G ENGLISH - SEE NCJ-56694)

NCJ Number
56698
Author(s)
I HADAR
Date Published
1977
Length
6 pages
Annotation
CORRECTIONS IN THE UNITED STATES IS COMPARED WITH CORRECTIONS IN EUROPEAN COUNTRIES, ALONG WITH PUBLIC ATTITUDES TOWARD CORRECTIONAL POLICIES.
Abstract
IN THE UNITED STATES, THE PUBLIC'S ATTITUDES TOWARD THE TREATMENT OF OFFENDERS DIFFERS SIGNIFICANTLY FROM THE ATTITUDES OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE PERSONNEL WHOSE PERSPECTIVES ARE MOLDED BY SPECIALIZED KNOWLEDGE AND EMPIRICAL STUDIES COMBINED WITH EXPERIENCE. THE PUBLIC GENERALLY HAS A SIMPLISTIC VIEW OF CORRECTIONS AS ESSENTIALLY PUNISHMENT METED OUT TO THE OFFENDER BECAUSE HE HAS DONE WRONG. IF THE CRIME RATE IS INCREASING, THE PUBLIC GENERALLY ASSUMES IT IS BECAUSE PUNISHMENTS HAVE NOT BEEN SEVERE ENOUGH. EVEN THOUGH CRIMINAL JUSTICE PERSONNEL KNOW THAT PUBLIC ATTITUDES ARE FLAWED, VERY LITTLE EFFORT HAS BEEN MADE TO INCREASE PUBLIC KNOWLEDGE ABOUT WHAT IS INVOLVED IN THE COMPLEXITIES OF CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR AND EFFORTS TO MODIFY AND CONTAIN IT. MOST OFTEN, THE VISIBLE INSTRUCTORS OF THE PUBLIC ABOUT CRIMINAL JUSTICE HAVE BEEN POLITICIANS, WHO PREY UPON THE PUBLIC'S FEARS AND FRUSTRATIONS BY CALLING FOR EVEN MORE HARSH PENALTIES FOR OFFENDERS. IN MOST WESTERN EUROPEAN COUNTRIES, HOWEVER, THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM IS DIVORCED FROM POLITICS AND GENERALLY LEFT TO WELL-TRAINED CRIMINAL JUSTICE PROFESSIONALS. THE PUBLIC TENDS TO VIEW OFFENDERS AS DISADVANTAGED CITIZENS WHO REQUIRE THE SPECIAL SERVICES OF THE STATE IN ORDER TO BE REHABILITATED, INSTEAD OF 'BAD GUYS' WHO DESERVE TO BE ISOLATED FROM THE 'GOOD GUYS' AND BE SEVERELY PUNISHED. EUROPEAN COUNTRIES ALSO HAVE MUCH SHORTER PRISON SENTENCES THAN DOES THE UNITED STATES. SHORTER PRISON TERMS ARE SUGGESTED, WITH REHABILITATION BEING OFFERED BUT NOT COERCED IN PRISON. TO BE EFFECTIVE, REHABILITATION MUST BE VOLUNTARY. IT IS SUGGESTED THAT EMPHASIS BE PLACED UPON POSITIVE PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT IN CHILDHOOD THROUGH TEACHING PARENTS HOW TO GUIDE THEIR CHILDREN IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF CONSTRUCTIVE SOCIAL VALUES AND BEHAVIOR. (RCB)