U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

PRIMARY AFFECTIVE DISORDER, AGGRESSION, AND CRIMINALITY A REVIEW AND CLINICAL STUDY

NCJ Number
56765
Journal
Archives of General Psychiatry Volume: 35 Issue: 8 Dated: (AUGUST 1978) Pages: 954-960
Author(s)
M I GOOD
Date Published
1978
Length
7 pages
Annotation
A LITERATURE REVIEW REGARDING AGGRESSIVE AND CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR AMONG PATIENTS WITH MANIC AND DEPRESSIVE CONDITIONS IS PRESENTED ALONG WITH A STUDY OF 100 INMATES AIMED AT IDENTIFYING SUBJECTS WITH THESE CONDITIONS.
Abstract
A STUDY WAS MADE AT MASSACHUSETTS CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION OF CONSECUTIVE PRISONERS (89 WOMEN, 11 MEN) REFERRED FOR PSYCHIATRIC EVALUATION. THE STUDY WAS INITIATED WHEN IT BECAME EVIDENT THAT A NUMBER OF INMATES WITH ACUTE MANIA HAD NOT BEEN DIAGNOSED PREVIOUSLY AS HAVING SUCH DISORDERS. A COMPARATIVELY HIGH INCIDENCE (10 PERCENT) OF PRIMARY AFFECTIVE DISORDER WAS FOUND IN THIS STUDY, WHICH HYPOTHESIZED THAT MANIC DEPRESSIVE STATES MAY BE UNDERDIAGNOSED IN THE UNITED STATES. SEVEN ADDITIONAL PATIENTS HAD EQUIVOCAL, DEFERRED, OR SCHIZOAFFECTIVE DIAGNOSES. SEVEN OF THE PATIENTS WITH PRIMARY AFFECTIVE DISORDER HAD BIPOLAR MOOD SWINGS, TWO WERE UNIPOLAR OR WITHOUT DEFINITE EVIDENCE OF MANIA, AND ONE WAS UNIPOLAR WITH POSSIBLE BIPOLARITY. SIGNIFICANTLY, IN ONLY TWO CASES WAS THE AFFECTIVE DIAGNOSIS KNOWN OR AVAILABLE AT THE TIME OF COMMITMENT TO PRISON; IN ONE CASE DIAGNOSIS WAS MADE AFTER COMMITMENT WHEN A HISTORY WAS GIVEN. IN THE REMAINING SEVEN CASES, EITHER NO PREVIOUS DIAGNOSIS WAS AVAILABLE OR THE DIAGNOSIS MERITED REVISION. SEVERAL FACTORS MAY CONTRIBUTE TO UNDERDIAGNOSIS OF PRIMARY AFFECTIVE DISORDER. AMONG THESE ARE MASKED DIAGNOSIS (EXCLUSION OF PATIENTS FROM DIAGNOSIS BECAUSE OF PAST ACTIONS OR THEIR IDENTIFICATION AS PRISONERS), MISLABELING OF THE DISORDER LEADING TO INCORRECT DIAGNOSIS, AND INSTITUTIONAL COMPARTMENTALISM AND AND INADEQUATE LIAISON BETWEEN PRISONS AND PSYCHIATRIC WORKERS. THE REPORT INCLUDES CASE HISTORIES OF THE 10 MANIC DEPRESSIVE PATIENTS, TABULAR DATA, AND A LIST OF REFERENCES. (MJW)