U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

INMATE MOVEMENTS AND PRISON UPRISINGS - A COMPARATIVE STUDY

NCJ Number
61223
Journal
Social Science Quarterly Volume: 59 Issue: 3 Dated: (DECEMBER 1978) Pages: 509-524
Author(s)
W D PEDERSON
Date Published
1978
Length
16 pages
Annotation
A COMPARATIVE HISTORIC STUDY OF INMATE BEHAVIOR UNDER VARYING CONDITIONS OF CONFINEMENT IS USED TO TEST THE APPLICATION OF RELATIVE-DEPRIVATION MODELS OF POLITICAL VIOLENCE TO INMATE MOVEMENTS AND UPRISINGS.
Abstract
DAVIES' PROGRESSIVE DEPRIVATION, OR J-CURVE, EXPLANATION OF POLITICAL VIOLENCE IS BASED ON STRUCTURAL AND ATTITUDINAL VARIABLES; THE THEORY STATES THAT POLITICAL VIOLENCE IS MOST LIKELY AFTER A PROLONGED PERIOD OF RISING EXPECTATIONS AND GRATIFICATIONS (THE PROSPERITY MODEL), FOLLOWED BY A SHORT PERIOD OF SHARP REVERSAL (THE MISERY MODEL) DURING WHICH THE GAP BETWEEN EXPECTATIONS AND GRATIFICATIONS QUICKLY WIDENS AND BECOMES INTOLERABLE. A COMPARATIVE HISTORIC STUDY OF INMATE BEHAVIOR IN WORLD WAR II JAPANESE-AMERICAN CAMPS, NAZI CONCENTRATION CAMPS, SOVIET LABOR CAMPS, AMERICAN MILITARY STOCKADES, AND AMERICAN PENITENTIARIES DEMONSTRATES THAT THE RELATIVE-DEPRIVATION MODEL IS APPLICABLE TO PRISON VIOLENCE. FINDINGS REVEAL THE FOLLOWING: (1) EXTREME DEPRIVATION RESULTS IN INMATE APATHY; (2) AS CONDITIONS IMPROVE, INMATE INTERACTION INCREASES AND REBELLION IS UNLIKELY; (3) IF CONDITIONS AND EXPECTATIONS RAPIDLY DECLINE, INMATE SOLIDARITY IN OPPOSITION TO THE AUTHORITIES INCREASES; (4) CERTAIN STRUCTURAL CATEGORIES OF INMATES ARE PRONE TO RELATIVE DEPRIVATION; AND (5) THERE IS A TEMPORAL RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN OUTSIDE EVENTS AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF INMATE MOVEMENTS; FOR EXAMPLE, DURING OUTSIDE WARTIME PROTESTS OR SEVERE SOCIAL CONFLICT. INMATE MOVEMENTS ARE RARE COMPARED TO ISOLATED, NONSERIAL PRISON UPRISINGS. THE J-CURVE MODEL OF RELATIVE DEPRIVATION IS USEFUL FOR EXPLAINING WHEN AND WHY INMATE MOVEMENTS OCCUR BY EXAMINING THE INTERACTION OF ATTITUDINAL, STRUCTURAL, AND TEMPORAL FACTORS. REFERENCES ARE PROVIDED.