U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

DETERRENCE, POVERTY, AND TYPE OF HOMICIDE

NCJ Number
66260
Journal
American Journal of Sociology Volume: 85 Issue: 3 Dated: (1979) Pages: 614-624
Author(s)
R N PARKER; M D SMITH
Date Published
1979
Length
11 pages
Annotation
USING NEWLY AVAILABLE DATA, THIS ANALYSIS CLASSIFIES HOMICIDE INTO TWO TYPES, PRIMARY AND NON-PRIMARY, BASED ON THE VICTIM/OFFENDER RELATIONSHIP.
Abstract
TWO MODELS THAT HAVE APPEARED IN RESEARCH LITERATURE ARE REPLICATED, USING THIS CLASSIFICATORY SCHEME. DATA ANALYZED WERE FOUND IN U.S. GOVERNMENT REPORTS, THE EFFECTS OF PARTITIONING HOMICIDE BY TYPE ON THE ESTIMATION OF THE DETERRENCE AND ETIOLOGICAL MODELS WERE EXPLORED. PRIMARY HOMICIDE INVOLVES FAMILY OR ACQUAINTANCES AND IS USUALLY AN ACT OF PASSION, WHILE NONPRIMARY HOMICIDES ARE OFEN INSTRUMENTAL IN NATURE SINCE THEY GENERALLY OCCUR IN THE COMMISSION OF ANOTHER CRIME (GANGLAND SLAYINGS, FELONY HOMICIDE, INSTITUTIONAL HOMICIDE). THE TWO TYPES OF HOMICIDE CAN BE VIEWED AS HAVING DIFFERENT ORIGINS: PRIMARY HOMICIDES BEING ESSENTIALLY UNREASONED ACTS OF PASSION AND NONPRIMARY HOMICIDE INVOLVING SOME DEGREE OF DECISIONMAKING OR MEDITATION. STUDY FINDINGS SHOWED LITTLE SUPPORT FOR THE DETERENCE MODEL AND CONSIDERABLE SUPPORT FOR THE ETIOLOGICAL MODEL. STATE PRIMARY-HOMICIDE RATES WERE FOUND TO BE RELATED TO POVERTY AND TO THE PERCENTAGE OF THE POPULATION AGED 20-34, WHILE NONPRIMARY HOMICIDE RATES WERE SIGNIFICANTLY RELATED ONLY TO THE PERCENTAGE OF THE STATE POPULATION LIVING IN URBAN AREAS. THE ANALYSIS SUGGESTS THAT PUNISHMENT APPEARS TO HAVE LITTEL EFFECT ON THE MAJORITY OF HOMICIDES SINCE THEY TEND TO OCCUR UNDER CIRCUMSTANCES IN WHICH LAWS, PRACTICES, AND PERCEPTIONS HAVE LITTLE IMPACT. RESULTS SHOWED THAT WHILE THE VARIABLES COMMONLY USED TO PREDICT HOMICIDE RATES WERE SUCCESSFUL IN PREDICTING PRIMARY HOMICIDE RATES, THEY WERE LESS SUCCESSFUL IN ACCOUNTING FOR NONPRIMARY HOMICIDE RATES. FURTHER STUDY IS NECESSARY TO DEVELOP A GREATER UNDERSTANDING OF THE FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO NONPRIMARY HOMICIDE. TABULAR DATA, NOTES, AND REFERENCES ARE INCLUDED. (MJW)