U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

"Authenticity Error" in Real Lineup Procedures. Effects of Suspect-Status and Corresponding Psychological Dissimilarities between Target Person and Distractors: An Experimental Study (From Psychology, Law, and Criminal Justice: International Developments in Research and Practice, P 29-38, 1996, Grah

NCJ Number
171510
Author(s)
T Fabian; M Stadler; P Wetzels
Date Published
1996
Length
10 pages
Annotation
This article reports on several studies of lineup procedures and possible errors that could affect the validity of lineup results.
Abstract
The results of a lineup procedure can be used as evidence in court only if the witness recognizes the suspect exclusively because of the similarity between the person identified in the lineup and the mnemonic representation of the person seen before in the situation of the criminal act. The article examines some of the errors and reports on hypotheses derived from assumptions about lineup procedures: (1) Suspects differ in their psychological states from non-suspects used as distractors (usually policemen) in real lineup procedures; (2) Suspects' behavior in a real lineup is perceived as more authentic than the behavior of persons used as distractors; (3) It is possible for non-witnesses to identify a suspect in a lineup procedure although they have never seen him before because of his different psychological state and his greater behavioral authenticity revealed by non-verbal cues; (4) Suspects who are merely asked whether or not there is a suspect in the lineup will more often answer "I don't know" than those who are told there is a suspect in the lineup; and (5) Subjects who are told there is a suspect in the lineup will more often choose the target person than subjects who are only asked whether or not there is a suspect in the lineup. Tables, figures, references

Downloads

No download available

Availability