U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

DANGERS OF POLITICAL NAIVETE AND EXCESSIVE COMPLEXITY IN EVALUATING DELINQUENCY PREVENTION PROGRAMS

NCJ Number
55954
Journal
Evaluation and Program Planning Volume: 1 Issue: 4 Dated: (1978) Pages: 273-283
Author(s)
J C HACKLER
Date Published
1978
Length
11 pages
Annotation
THIS PAPER ARGUES THAT EFFORTS TO LAUNCH EXCESSIVELY COMPLEX DELINQUENCY PREVENTION PROGRAM EVALUATIONS ARE DOOMED TO FAIL AND MAY INTERFERE WITH THE BENEFITS OF THE PROGRAM AND THE OVERALL PREVENTION EFFORT.
Abstract
THE TRADITIONAL EXPERIMENTAL-CONTROL GROUP PROCEDURES USED IN EVALUATING PROGRAMS ARE RARELY SUCCESSFUL WITH DELINQUENCY PREVENTION PROGRAMS SINCE SELECTION OF RANDOM SAMPLES IS NEARLY IMPOSSIBLE AND IS USUALLY REPLACED WITH RECRUITMENT OF A COMPARISON GROUP. FURTHERMORE, THE PROCEDURES CREATE STRESS WHICH ENDANGERS THE OVERALL SUCCESS OF THE PROGRAMS AND PRODUCE HOSTILITY ON THE PART OF PROGRAM STAFF AGAINST RESEARCHERS ATTEMPTING TO GAIN KNOWLEDGE ABOUT THE IMPACTS OF A PROGRAM. COMPLEX EVALUATION PROGRAMS ONLY INCREASE THE LIKELIHOOD OF STRESS. AN ILLUSTRATION OF AN INAPPROPRIATELY COMPLEX RESEARCH DESIGN IS PRESENTED TO SHOW THAT EACH ATTEMPT TO INTRODUCE AND CONTROL FOR A NEW EXPERIMENTAL VARIABLE INCREASES THE RISK OF COMING INTO CONFLICT WITH THE COMMUNITY, ANOTHER AGENCY, OR MEMBERS OF THE PROJECT STAFF. THESE TYPES OF CONFLICTS ENLARGE THE POSSIBILITY OF ERROR JUDGMENTS ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIPS AND INTERACTIONS AMONG VARIABLES AND ABOUT THE INTEGRITY OF THEIR USE. IF SOPHISTICATED RESEARCH SKILLS WERE DIRECTED TOWARD THE ANALYSIS OF DATA GATHERED FROM LARGER NUMBERS OF CASES AND FROM MORE READILY AVAILABLE DATA SOURCES, MANY OF THE NEGATIVE CONSEQUENCES OF EVALUATIONS COULD BE MINIMIZED. HOW FINDINGS ARE TREATED IS AN IMPORTANT FACTOR SINCE THE EVALUATION RESULTS ARE PRESENTED IN A POLITICAL ARENA AND CAN HAVE GREAT IMPLICATIONS FOR THE PROGRAMS. OBJECTIVE ASSESSMENT MAY DAMAGE FLEDGLING PROJECTS WITHOUT ALTERING INEFFECTIVE BUT ENTRENCHED PROGRAMS. RESEARCHERS SHOULD BE OBSERVERS RATHER THAN DOERS AND SHOULD FOCUS ON THE TASK OF OBSERVING, GATHERING, AND MARITAL DISPUTES, INDIVIDUAL PROBLEMS, NEIGHBORHOOD EVALUATION. REFERENCES ARE PROVIDED. (DAG)